When Irish (Research) Eyes Are Smiling
Filed under: Genealogy Tips on Thursday, March 4th, 2010 by Erica | No CommentsBy: Carolyn L. Barkley
A version of this article first appeared in this blog in March 2008. While not many postings collect comments, this article received five, from as far away as Ireland, from Holdcraft descendants with ties to the family in Frederick County, Maryland. Those comments were very rewarding to read and fulfilled one of the goals of this blog – connecting people with common interests or ancestors. Please note: Sometime after the original posting, the blog began to require registration in order to leave comments as a result of the enormous number of spam messages that were being received. I will be the first to acknowledge that the registration process does not always work, but please be assured that we are working on the problem as we value comments like the ones received for this article. Please revisit the original posting to read its interesting comments. The following article is an update to the original.
Wednesday, March 17th will be the day when everyone claims to be Irish. For many of you, however, your research has documented a bit – or a lot – of green in your family tree. You may have known of such ethnic connections prior to your research, with family surnames such as O’Meara, Hennessey and others. For some of us, the discovery may have been more serendipitous.
Some years ago, tired of the brick walls in my own research lines, I turned to my son’s paternal ancestral lines for a fresh start. I knew that his great-grandmother’s maiden name was Susan Holdcraft and that she lived in Frederick County, Maryland, but not much more. Having looked at the name from time-to-time, I had assumed (never a good thing to do) that the surname was German. Knowing absolutely nothing about German genealogical research, I ran in the other direction! The time, however, had finally come to do some research into the Holdcrafts, German content or not.
An IGI search revealed that Susan was born 12 February 1870 at Brook Hill in Frederick County, Maryland, the daughter of James Patrick [alternately given as Patrick James] Holdcraft and Catherine Anne Sophia Dutrow. No sources were provided for the entry. The Dutrow line clearly would lead to German research as it included surnames such as Ramsburg and Devilbiss. A further IGI search (again no sources) indicated that James Patrick Holdcraft was born in September 1836 at Keagh’s Cross, co. Louth, Ireland, the son of James Holdcraft and Rose McCabe. A James Patrick Holdcraft was in the United States at the time of the Civil War, and in June 1861 enlisted in Co. K of the 5th Regiment, Massachusetts Foot Volunteers, later Co. K of the 9th Massachusetts Infantry. Left behind by his unit in Maryland in 1862, he stayed in Maryland so long that he feared arrest on charges of desertion and enlisted in Co. D of the H1st Regiment Potomac Home Brigade, Maryland Cavalry, on 29 July 1863, but did so under the name of James E. McCabe. When I read all of his service records, an enormous (three folders) widow’s pension file and consulted Frederick County records, I was able to document that the James Patrick Holdcraft who was born in co. Louth and the James E. McCabe who served in the Maryland Cavalry were the same individual – the James Patrick Holdcraft who married Catherine Ann Sophia Dutrow. I then had Irish research to pursue (while letting the German lines continue to languish). I am sorry to say that in the intervening year between the first posting of this article and this year’s revision, I have not continued this work. I hope to do so during my trip to Salt Lake City during the National Genealogical Society conference in late April. If I find additional information, I will be writing further about this family.
Whenever you begin research in a new geographical area, whether in the United States or elsewhere, the best way to begin is by reading a good overall research guide. For Ireland, one of the best is the third edition of John Grenham’s Tracing Your Irish Ancestors (Genealogical Publishing Co., 2006). Grenham discusses major record groups (civil records, census records, church records and land records) as well as wills, emigration, deeds, newspapers, and directories. Ireland also has distinctive genealogical records, including Griffith’s Valuation (index available on CD from genealogical.com), Title Applotment Books (available on CD from genealogical.com), flax tax records and more. In addition to providing an understanding of these various types of records, Tracing Your Irish Ancestors includes county source lists. To assist me in my Holdcraft research, I was able to find a list of co. Louth census returns and substitutes beginning in 1600 and ending in 1911. The census substitutes include such things as voter lists, a 1796 Spinning-Wheel Premium List, and Brewers Lists. In addition, Grenham also lists local histories, local journals, directories and county guides, published gravestone inscriptions, and estate record lists. A section on Roman Catholic registers includes a map of co. Louth showing twenty-three churches in three dioceses and listing extant baptismal, marriage and burial registers. I now know what records are available, often where they are located, and can read about the purpose, content and use of each. Now I just need to find the time to continue my research!
An additional strategy for learning about new areas and resources is to attend national conference and to attend lectures by experts in the field. David Rencher, Elizabeth Kelly Kerstens, and Paul Milner are several lecturers to look for on conference programs. This year’s program for the National Genealogical Society Conference in the States in Salt Lake City (28 April – 1 May) includes four lectures related to Irish research.
Among the 172 Irish research titles available from genealogical.com are:
Irish Flax Growers List, 1796 (available on CD)
A Topographical Dictionary of Ireland by Samuel Lewis (Clearfield, 2004; two volume set currently out of print, but currently available on CD)
A New Genealogical Atlas of Ireland by Brian Mitchell (second edition, Genealogical Publishing Co., 2008)
A Guide to Irish Parish Registers by Brian Mitchell (Genealogical Publishing Co., 2009)
General Alphabetical Index to the Townlands and Towns, Parishes and Baronies of Ireland (Genealogical Publishing Co., 2006)
Land Owners in Ireland 1876 (Genealogical Publishing Co.; currently on sale at genealogical.com)
Selected additional resources include:
Duffy, Sean, ed. The Macmillan Atlas of Irish History (Macmillan, 1997)
Grenham, John. Grenham’s Irish Surnames (CD from Eneclann Ltd.)
Index of Irish Wills, 1848-1858 (CD from Eneclann Ltd.)
MacLysaght, Edward. The Surnames of Ireland (6th edition from Irish Academic Pres, 1991)
Ryan, James G. Irish Records: Sources for Family and Local History (Ancestry, 1988)
Cyndi’s List. Ireland and North Ireland Section
Family History Library. Place name search for Ireland and research guides for Ireland.